质疑井冈山大学“严肃处理两教师学术造假事件”

30 12 2009年

    井冈山大学校方在获知两名教师被一次撤掉70篇论文的消息后不到一周,就做出了开除这两名教师的公职的决定,如此雷厉风行,当然要归功于两名犯事的教师既非大牌教授,更非校领导,不过是两个讲师。但是看了井冈山大学校方公布的调查、处理结果,有两点令人难以理解:

    一、调查结果称追回钟华所有造假论文的全部奖励3.2万元,而刘涛的造假论文因内容不属于其专业研究范围,未予奖励。但是查井冈山大学《2007年论文奖励汇总表》,刘涛的28篇造假论文和钟华的39篇造假论文都在奖励之列,难道这个论文奖励汇总表是闹着玩的?如果刘涛的全部造假论文和钟华的大部分造假论文都得不到奖励,他们费心思一篇篇地造那么多假论文干什么呢?就为了帮助井冈山大学在国际上出名吗?

    二、这两教师的造假论文都不是自己一个人署名,钟华的造假论文共有12个共同作者,刘涛的造假论文共有4名共同作者。这些共同作者应该承担什么责任呢?按井冈山大学的处理结果,似乎是说这些共同作者的名义都被盗用了。这些造假论文已发表了两年,两位教师用它们来评职称、获得奖励,他们的同事居然此前都没有发现自己的名义被盗用?这些“名义被盗用”的共同作者对这份杂志并不陌生,有的也在上面大量地发表论文,例如刘荫秋自己就在上面发了13篇第一作者论文。其中化工学院前任院长曾锡瑞是多篇造假论文的共同作者,他此前也不看申报奖励的论文,完全不知情吗?(井冈山英雄在该杂志发表论文时喜欢让老院长沾光,有老院长大名的论文达38篇,老院长应赶快声明所有这些论文都和他无关)如果是为了便于发表而去盗用著名权威的名义,还可理解,但是这份杂志是不审稿的,盗用他人的名义有什么用?难道是为了陷害这些同事?

附:
严格依法依规治校  严惩学术不端行为

我校严肃处理两教师学术造假事件

2009年12月19日,国际学术期刊《Acta crystallographica. Section E, Structure Reports Online》(《晶体学报,E辑:结构报告网络版》)官方网站发表社论,公布了以我校化学化工学院讲师、硕士钟华和工学院讲师、硕士刘涛为责任人,发表在该刊物的70篇论文存在造假现象,并作出一次性撤消的决定。

2009年12月23日下午,学校有关部门获知两名老师涉嫌学术造假的消息后,立即向学校进行汇报。学校对此高度重视,根据学校主要领导的指示,当天晚上就召开了相关部门负责人会议,决定就有关情况进行初步调查核实,并形成了初步处理方案:成立学校和学院调查小组和有关学科的专家鉴定组,立即开展核查工作;自12月23日起,对两名当事人予以停职调查,由于钟华正在外地学习,要求其立即回校接受调查;立即撤销当事人有关学术成果,追缴已发放的相应奖励;将根据核查结果,依法依规对当事人做出进一步严肃处理。

12月24日上午,学校将情况向上级有关部门汇报。12月27日下午,学校专门听取了调查小组的调查情况汇报。12月26日晚,学校党委书记万继抗、校长张泰城在接受《中国之声》新闻纵横栏目记者采访时,对事件作了正面回应,表明了学校的态度。

12月28日晚,学校学术委员会召开第六次全体会议,听取了事件调查组对钟华和刘涛两名教师学术不端行为的调查报告,与会委员对事件进行了学术评判。校学术委员会认定钟华有以下学术不端行为事实:伪造及篡改数据,制造虚假论文公开发表;伪造及篡改数据,替他人制造虚假论文公开发表;未经他人许可,盗用他人名义作为合作作者发表造假论文;造假论文数量特别多。校学术委员会认定刘涛有以下学术不端行为事实:要求钟华代写论文并提供条件,构成造假授权事实;持造假论文骗取成果确认;未经他人许可,盗用他人名义作为合作作者发表造假论文。造假论文数量特别多。

校学术委员会认为,钟华、刘涛的以上行为事实分别属于教育部《关于严肃处理高等学校学术不端行为的通知》中列举的“伪造或篡改数据”、“侵吞他人学术成果”、“未参加创作,在他人学术成果上署名”和“未经他人许可,不当使用他人署名”等学术不端行为类型,情节特别严重,影响特别恶劣,属于严重的学术不端行为。

为捍卫学术尊严,根据教育部《关于严肃处理高等学校学术不端行为的通知》、江西省教育厅《关于树立社会主义荣辱观,进一步加强教育系统学术道德建设的意见》和《井冈山大学科研行为道德规范》的相关规定,学校决定对钟华和刘涛作如下行政处理:撤销钟华的造假学术成果,追回所有造假论文的全部奖励3.2万元;撤销刘涛的造假学术成果(因其论文内容不属于其专业研究范围,按学校规定,未予奖励);报请上级主管部门撤销钟华、刘涛的高等学校教师资格;解聘钟华、刘涛的高等学校讲师专业技术职务;撤销钟华、刘涛的高等学校讲师专业技术资格;报请上级主管部门撤销钟华于2009年12月15日获得的高等学校副教授专业技术资格;开除钟华、刘涛的公职。钟华为中共党员,鉴于其所犯错误事实,为了严肃党纪,教育本人,警示他人,根据《中国共产党纪律处分条例》和《中共中央纪律检查委员会关于共产党员违反社会主义道德党纪处分的若干规定》,给予钟华开除党籍的处分。

近年来,我校在发展过程中,始终注重对教师进行学术道德教育,对教师科研成果进行规范管理。2006年1月1日发布了《井冈山大学科研行为道德规范(试行)》;学校学术委员会多次主持召开全校性学术道德会议,强调学术规范;学校党政主要领导在全校性重要会议上多次强调,教师要珍惜自己特别是学校的声誉,要坚决杜绝学术不端行为。

近期,学校将在全校开展“规范学术行为,加强诚信教育”专题教育活动。

钟华、刘涛学术造假事件发生以后,学校深感痛心,又十分愤慨。虽然这是我校个别教师的个人行为,但对学校声誉造成了重大损害。学校将认真吸取教训,进一步加大对师生的学术规范教育,对科研工作进行更加严格的管理,坚决杜绝学术不端行为再次发生。


操作

文章信息

36篇回复 to “质疑井冈山大学“严肃处理两教师学术造假事件””

6 01 2010年
typp1978 (10:49:32) :

最近研究C3I,查了些文献,结果把文献一对比,才发现国内真的是毫无忌惮的,大家可以看看武汉科技大学这位陈建勋教授的论文发表方法:
1A:基于WEB服务和CORBA的C^3I网络管理系统的研究 《计算机工程与应用》
2005年第41卷第18期 陈建勋[1] 张子鹤[2] 夏学知[2]
1B C3I网络管理体系结构研究 《计算机工程与设计》2005年第26卷第4期
陈建勋[1] 夏学知[2] 张子鹤[2]

2A 基于UML的C3I仿真测试环境的建模方法研究
>2005年 第28卷 第02期
作者: 陈建勋, 伍江华,
2B 基于UML的C3I仿真测试环境建模研究
>2006年 第30卷 第05期
作者: 伍江华, 张子鹤, 陈建勋, 夏学知,

3A C3I系统仿真测试环境的设计与实现
>2006年 第23卷 第02期
作者: 夏学知, 陈建勋, 伍江华, 张子鹤,
3B 领域分析在C3I仿真测试环境中的应用
计算机仿真 > 2006年5期 >
伍江华[1,2] 马于涛[3] 张子鹤[2] 陈建勋[1,2]

4A 基于软件体系结构的组件集成框架
陈建勋[1] 张子鹤[2] 马于涛[3] 夏学知[2]
《计算机工程》2004年第30卷第22期
4B 基于UML的软件体系结构建模技术的研究
马于涛 陈建勋
《武汉科技大学学报:自然科学版》2003年第26卷第3期

这几篇和我正研究的C3I相关,确实高,内容到处借鉴不说,还会万般变换
再查该教授其它论文,几乎全是这样,不炮制决不罢休的样子,好像根本就不怕别人戳穿
5A 基于整数小波变换和混沌映射的盲数字水印算法
余波[1] 陈建勋[1] 简炜[2] 孙希平[2]
5B 基于小波变换和人类视觉系统的盲数字水印算法
赵辉 余波 陈建勋
5C 基于小波变换和神经网络的盲数字水印算法
李顺新[1] 胡名雨[1] 余波[2] 陈建勋[2]

看该教授网站,博导、院长,不知如何培养学生!!

17 07 2018年
top online marketing firm (20:12:32) :

top online marketing firm…

方舟子的Blog …

25 07 2018年
cafef.vn (00:08:56) :

4. Mức khấu trừ trong các loại hình bảo hiểm.

25 07 2018年
sua chua dieu hoa (06:24:40) :

Hey there just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let
you know a few of the pictures aren’t loading properly.

I’m not sure why but I think its a linking issue. I’ve
tried it in two different web browsers and both show the same results.

27 07 2018年
ngoisao.net (05:58:38) :

Chi phí trị sẹo thâm mỗi lần từ 1,2 triệu.

28 07 2018年
im1music (08:53:55) :

This web site definitely has all of the information I needed concerning this subject and didn’t know who to ask.

28 07 2018年
fortnite mobile cheats (20:26:32) :

I ԝas suggested this wweƄ site by my cousin. I am
not sure whether this postt іs written Ƅy him as nobody else know such detailed about mү prⲟblem.
You are amazing! Tһanks!

29 07 2018年
https://www.anestencream.com (11:43:09) :

Hi there! Do you know iff they make any plugins too safeguard against hackers?

I’m kinda paraqnoid abbout lopsing everything I’ve worked hard on. Any suggestions?

30 07 2018年
weilbet (17:22:48) :

Howdy! Someone in my Myspace group shared this website
with us so I came to give it a look. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m bookmarking and will be
tweeting this to my followers! Fantastic blog
and terrific design and style.

5 08 2018年
top blog sites to use (07:54:34) :

I truly love ʏour site.. Very nice colors & theme. Did you create this ѡebsite yourself?
Please reply bacқ as I’m looking to create my veгy own website and would liқe
to find out where you got this from or just what the theme
iѕ named. Thanks!

7 08 2018年
fr homownrs insuranc quots (04:11:54) :

But one thing that can really dampen or perhaps ruin any
occasion or trip overseas is losing a wallet
or other valuable items. Now do you know what you have
to do see what’s available to you available by searching online at
specialized websites that will help you discover providers and plans with your area.
In this insurance it covers fire or lightening, explosions, aircraft, theft or vandalism, weight of ice when there
is snow storm, falling objects, vehicles, smoke, air cooling, windstorm and freezing of plumbing, or another systems that
occur inside your house.

7 08 2018年
online marketer (07:30:13) :

marketing guru…

blog topic…

7 08 2018年
test (07:36:28) :

recipe almond macaroons…

blog topic…

7 08 2018年
artigo (08:21:19) :

AD Monografias Online | Compra e venda de tcc…

blog topic…

9 08 2018年
xclusivejams (02:55:11) :

I blog often and I genuinely thank you for your content.
This article has truly peaked my interest. I will take a note of
your site and keep checking for new information about once per week.

I subscribed to your Feed as well.

9 08 2018年
Travel (03:20:32) :

vacation…

blog topic…

9 08 2018年
dieta 9 kilos em tres dias (07:00:17) :

oi . Você poderia me dizer qual plataforma você está usando neste site ?
Muito em breve estarei construindo meu mini portal mas tenho dúvidas
sobre qual plataforma usar e gostei muito o formato do seu site
. Se puder me informar , será de grande ajuda .
agradeço antecipadamente https://Sanjatuwet.com/die-ewige-jugend/

9 08 2018年
recipe air fryer chicken (18:52:14) :

hi!,I like your writing very a lot! share we keep up a correspondence extra approximately your article on AOL?
I require a specialist in this house to unravel my problem.

May be that is you! Having a look forward to look you.

10 08 2018年
Julienne (01:46:24) :

I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here.
The sketch is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish.
nonetheless, you command get got an edginess over that you wish be delivering
the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again since exactly the same
nearly a lot often inside case you shield this
increase.

10 08 2018年
denver seo company (01:58:58) :

denver seo agency…

blog topic…

10 08 2018年
hackgamez.com (03:23:26) :

The dungeon in Hack 1.0.3 has no branches; there’s a technique
up and one way down.

10 08 2018年
healthy recipes dark chocolate (15:34:08) :

Hi friends, how is everything, and what you would
like to say concerning this piece of writing, in my
view its actually amazing designed for me.

10 08 2018年
property rate in mumbai area wise (15:56:10) :

Appreciation to my father who informed me regarding this website, this website is
actually awesome.

13 08 2018年
comedy claic (19:13:13) :

Netflix for me personally was the ability to not merely download and
stream movies but so that you can legally duplicate to DVD along with the cost for this unlimited
service. Often forced to live rough, sleeping in toilets and queue on top
of others for any room inside a hostel he seems to get himself while on an internship becoming a stock broker with the hope
of earning a greater, more secure future for his son. That’s right, the actual setting is
really developed and detailed who’s, by itself, plays as essential a task inside film because hero and villain.

22 08 2018年
unmanaged dedicated servers (02:05:59) :

I cant understand what you are saying

24 08 2018年
Situs BandarQ (21:11:00) :

Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your website and in accession capital to
assert that I get actually enjoyed account your blog posts.
Any way I will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

25 08 2018年
Maribel (18:23:44) :

It’s not my first time to visit this web site, i am browsing this web page dailly and take good information from here daily.

26 08 2018年
o general split ac 1 ton price (02:43:48) :

Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote
the book in it or something. I think that you can do with some
pics to drive the message home a little bit, but instead of that, this is
excellent blog. An excellent read. I’ll certainly be back.

31 08 2018年
kumpulan situs judi online (06:58:57) :

Hi there to every single one, it’s in fact a good for me
to go to see this web page, it contains priceless Information.

4 09 2018年
Geri (15:27:50) :

Gostei do esse apost, Parabéns, tu tem mais alguma postagem sobre
nesse assunto? Muito obrigado! http://bathbusinessweb.co.uk/company/universal-tool-hire-and-supplies/

12 09 2018年
cần mua cồn khô (00:46:19) :

Hi there, i read your blog occasionally and i ⲟwn a similar
one and і was just curious іf you get а lot ߋf spam feedback?
If so һow do you prevent it, anyy plugin օr anything you can recommend?
I ɡet so much lately it’s driving me crazy
ѕo anny assistance is very much appreciated.

12 09 2018年
24 09 2018年
tac dung cua nam linh chi (19:15:48) :

In fact when someone doesn’t be aware of afterward its up
to other viewers that they will help, so here it takes place.

23 11 2018年
Blinds stores in winnipeg (07:34:13) :

And we South Africans are resourceful people.

28 11 2018年
Josh Webster (21:01:54) :

Howdy! Would you mind if I share your blog with my myspace group?
There’s a lot of people tjat I think woul really enjoy your content.

Please let me know. Manny thanks

29 11 2018年
www.youtube.com (16:14:48) :

First of all I would like to say fantastic blog! I had a quick question which I’d like to ask if you don’t mind.
I was curious to know how you center yourself and clear your
head before writing. I’ve had a difficult time clearing my mind in getting my
ideas out. I do enjoy writing but it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are wasted
just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or hints?
Thanks!

留言

您可以用这些标签 : <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>

CAPTCHA Image
*